The Human Genre Project

The Metaphor in Question

Chromosome 22 was the first to be sequenced. It was thought to be the shortest. It isn't. It is the first apple from the genomic tree.

"I live in a world of poetry," she said. "Everything seems significant to me. Everything has meaning. It's what gets me into trouble"

Una Persson in The Entropy Tango by Michael Moorcock.


History, besides BEING a metaphor
Is MADE of metaphors.

I want to EMPHASIZE that.

Evolution is a metaphor -
one that Charles Darwin
much resisted.

The word does not appear
In the eighteen fifty-nine
"Origin of Species"

("The survival of the fittest"
Didn't turn up till the fifth edition
and there as a quotation
from the work of Herbert Spencer)

Being classically educated
Darwin knew that "evolution"
means "a rolling out from"

He didn't like that a bit

Implicit in the word
is the idea that the organic present
has rolled
- progressively, Whiggishly
and inevitably –
from out of the past.

That’s what his predecessors (and successors)
Meant by the use of that metaphor
That's not what Darwin thought he saw
In the garden at Down
Or the volcanic lumps of the Encandatas

Niether did he see
The History of Life
As a ladder
From lower to higher

On his "entangled bank"
all life,
plant, insect, mould and duck
was exactly as "evolved"
as every other "form most beautiful"
Every bit as lovely...
Every bit as interesting


He didn't like his title either.

"Origin OF Species" was a
publisher's echo of the earlier
(Best selling)
"Vestiges OF Creation"
Robert Chamber's anonymous blockbuster
of 1844
To which, many people thought,
"Origins" was a sequel.

In Vestiges, Chambers talked
of "evolution"
of higher, better forms
succeeding, lower, simpler breeds
till at the pinnacle stood man
(white, male, possibly Scottish)
with mutton chops and a waistcoat -
a monkey's paw
fiddling in his pants

On the publication of Origins
(which didn't sell like hotcakes — or Vestiges)
Huxley, Darwin's bulldog, snapped at bishops

But Huxley never accepted -
Descent with modification
Naturally selected in the struggle for existance -
as the engine of life's changes

But he, like Herbert Spencer,
Andrew Carnegie, and, yes
Adolph Hitler
"believed" in "Darwin"

Darwin the metaphor, that is.


In the beginning, then
Man created Darwin
just as Man created God

as a metaphor
out of metaphors

as a belief
a cause
an explanation


The Revd Adam Sedgewick
Who taught Charley his geology
broke his pupil's heart
when he wrote to him
how he loved him
and hated his ideas.

But he had hated "Vestiges" more.
Despised it
Assuming the anonymous author
was a woman
Like Eve, seeking out of vanity
For things she shouldn't know.

Original Sin, also
Is a metaphor

But not for "knowing" No.
For "meaning"

Because till Eve took the apple
Nothing had a meaning
Everything had names for what they were,
no more
So there was no need for metaphors
In the Garden


Pace Aristotle
a human (since Eve)
is a "meaning" reed

It must have happened first in Africa
Possibly with a yam or a banana

We've been in trouble ever since

Peter Arnott